What Is a Eucharistic Miracle?

Discover Eucharistic Miracles on Praesentia

The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches us that the Eucharist is the “source and summit of the Christian life.” The Eucharist is one of the seven sacraments of the Church, and Catholics celebrate the Eucharist at every Mass. Jesus commanded this at the Last Supper, saying “Do this in memory of me” (Luke 22:19).

‍

During the consecration at Mass, the bread and wine on the altar truly become Christ’s Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity. The theological term for this is “transubstantiation.” 

‍

God accomplishes this through the priest’s ministry and the power of the Holy Spirit.

‍

Eucharistic miracles are rare events. The consecrated Host takes on the appearance of human flesh or blood, or displays other miraculous properties. 

‍

St. Thomas Aquinas writes about the possibility of this first type of Eucharistic miracle in his work, Summa Theologica.

‍

He explains how some aspects of the appearance of the Eucharist could stay the same while others could change, writing: “While the dimensions remain the same as before, there is a miraculous change wrought in the other accidents, such as shape, color, and the rest.”

‍

Diagram of accidents, or non-essential attributes, of the Eucharist.
Diagram of accidents, or non-essential attributes, of the Eucharist.

‍

What Does Science Teach Us About These Events?

A well-documented type of Eucharistic miracle is when a consecrated Host appears to bleed.

‍

As part of official investigations, Church officials have sometimes recruited scientists to analyze Hosts from these events. In 1970, the Host from a Eucharistic event at Lanciano underwent extensive scientific examination.

‍

Professor Edoardo Linoili, an expert in anatomy and histology, reported that the blood is Type AB. He also identified that the tissue came from the human heart.

‍

Remarkably, analyses of some other Eucharistic miracles have yielded strikingly similar results. For example, researchers analyzed a Host from a reported 1996 Eucharistic miracle in Buenos Aires, Argentina. Frederick Zugibe, a cardiologist, reported that the sample was also heart tissue. 

‍

Heart tissue Eucharistic miracle

‍

Where Have Eucharistic Miracles Happened?

Lanciano, Italy

In the 700s in Lanciano, Italy, a Basilian monk was celebrating Mass. Inside, he felt doubts about the reality of the Eucharist. When he had said the words of consecration, he saw the Host turn into flesh and the wine turn into blood. Those in attendance also witnessed what had happened.

‍

The flesh and blood were put in a reliquary, which is still on display in the Church of Saint Francis in Lanciano.

‍

Cúa, Venezuela

On December 8, 1991, Father Otty Ossa Aristizábal was celebrating midnight Mass at the Shrine of Betania.

‍

The priest later recalled that when he looked down at the paten, he noticed a red spot on one of the pieces of the Host. He described seeing a red substance emerge from it, “similar to the manner in which blood escapes from a wound.”

‍

A convent in Venezuela preserves the Host, and the faithful can view it there. Years later, an American pilgrim went to view the Host. He captured a video of the Host appearing to pulse, and surrounded by what looked to be flames.

‍

Ettoswil, Switzerland

In 1447, a Swiss member of a satanic group, Ann Vӧgtli, stole a pyx with a Host from a church. Passing through a graveyard, Ann could not hold the Host because it began to feel heavy. She decided to throw the Host into nearby bushes.

‍

Later, a swineherd named Margaret Schulmeister discovered the Eucharist. The Host was broken into seven pieces, forming an image of a flower. The parish priest was able to retrieve six of the pieces, but when he went to pick up the seventh piece, it sank into the ground.

‍

The priest had a chapel built on the site of this miracle for pilgrims and locals to see the miraculous Hosts that were retrieved. 

‍

Eucharistic Miracle of Siena, Italy

‍

A Saint Who Shared His Love of the Eucharist

St. Carlo Acutis was an Italian teenager whose love of the Eucharist inspired him to document Eucharistic miracles from around the world.

‍

Carlo was born in London to Italian parents in 1991. He showed a great love for Jesus in the Eucharist from his youth. At age seven, he begged to receive the Eucharist earlier than Church norms allowed for. His wish was granted.

‍

Later in life, he would visit the sites of Eucharistic miracles. Gifted with technology, Carlo created a website and exhibition documenting these miracles.

‍

He died from leukemia at age 15, but his incredible legacy lives on. His panels have been displayed in parishes around the globe. Carlo’s Eucharistic devotion is captured in his saying, “The Eucharist is my highway to Heaven.” 

‍

St. Carlo Acutis

‍

What Do Eucharistic Miracles Point To?

Ultimately, Eucharistic miracles should point us back to this truth: a miracle happens at every Mass. Jesus Christ becomes truly present in the Eucharist.

‍

Eucharistic miracles can challenge us to ask ourselves important questions about our own faith.

‍

How can I imitate the humility of Jesus in the Eucharist?

‍

Do I recognize that Jesus is present in the tabernacle of every Catholic Church? Do I prioritize spending time with him?

‍

How can I help others encounter the love of Jesus in the Eucharist?

‍

Jesus holding the Eucharist

‍

Praesentia on CatholicTV

Praesentia brings you amazing accounts of Eucharistic miracles that will deepen your meditation on this central mystery. Explore these miracles with host Rachel Bulman, who uses storytelling to bring these historical events to life. Tune in on Monday at 9pm ET on CatholicTV, and watch episodes online as well.

Share this post